By Arkadiusz Sieron – Re-Blogged From Gold Eagle
“We are in a bond market bubble that’s beginning to unwind.” This is the statement of Alan Greenspan. Is he right? We invite you to read today’s article about the US bond market and find out whether it is in bubble or not – and what does it all mean for the precious metals market.
Bond yields are in an upward trend since 2016/2017. And they hit the accelerator again last month. The 10-year Treasury yield topped 3.2 percent, the highest level since May 2011. Other yields have also increased recently: on 30-year Treasuries hit 3.40 in October, while on 5-year US government bonds jumped above 3 percent, as one can see in the chart below.
Chart 1. Daily yields (in %) on US Treasuries: 30-Year (red line), 10-year (orange line), 5-year (green line), 2-year (velvet line), 1-year (blue line) from January 2009 to October 2018.
For some analysts, such high levels are not sustainable. However, when you adopt a broader perspective, you will see that the bond yields are not extremely high. As the chart below shows, their current levels are still historically low. The bond yields used to be much higher in the past – and not only in the 1970s, when inflation raised its ugly head, but even in the early years after the Great Recession.
Chart 2. Monthly yields (in %) on US Treasuries: 30-Year (red line), 10-year (orange line), 5-year (green line), 2-year (velvet line), 1-year (blue line) from April 1953 to September 2018.
Actually, many analysts claim the opposite, arguing that bonds prices, which move inversely to yields, are too high. For example, Bill Gross, a famous bond investor, believes that the bear market in bond prices has just begun. Similarly, Alan Greenspan, the former Fed Chair has recently said that “we are in a bond market bubble that’s beginning to unwind”. And, at least this is an impression after reading an excerpt from the upcoming book by Paul Volcker, it seems that he would agree with Greenspan.
What is important here is the reason behind the recent moves. The yields increased because traders caught up with the FOMC projections for the federal funds rate next year. We have been warning investors for a long time that the divergence between traders’ bets and the Fed’s view would not last forever. About two months ago, traders were pricing just slightly more than one hike in 2019, even though the Fed forecasted three rate increases. Now, the market sees more than two hikes.
Importantly, the breakout in long-term yields made the yield curve steepen. The spread between 10-year and 2-year yields climbed above 30 basis points, rebounding to the level before the September slide, as one can see in the chart below. It’s quite funny as practically all analysts were forecasting the imminent inversion. We were skeptical about that popular narrative (see, for example, this article) and it turned out that we were right.
Chart 3: Yield curve (spread between 10-year and 2-year Treasury yields, in %) from January to October 2018.
However, what really matters is not who was right, but what we could expect for the bond and gold markets in the future. Will the yields on Treasuries continue its rally, or will we see a correction? And how will all this affect the precious metals?
Well, as the US central banks tapers its holdings just when the Treasury borrows so much, we should expect that yields will increase further. Many people worry that the increase in yields will burst the bond bubble. It could support the yellow metal, which is perceived as a substitute safe haven for Treasuries.
The only problem is that we have heard about the imminent sell-off for years. But the 10-year yields have recently spiked above 3 percent – and nothing happened. The reason for that is that the increase in yields is likely to occur not in a single, explosive upward move, but gradually over an extended period of time. Moreover, higher yield should spur renewed demand for bonds (if they generate higher income, they might look more attractive), moderating the impact of any sell-off.
The bottom line is that we could see even higher bond yields in the future. The Fed’s tightening of monetary policy combined with widening fiscal deficits should exert an upward pressure on rates. However, as the US central bank moves relatively slowly, the increase in yields is likely to also be gradual. The higher demand for bonds, in particular from foreign investors (just see what is happening in Italy or in certain emerging markets), should moderate the pressure on bond prices. The gradual rise in yields should not demolish the gold market, but it will not help the yellow metal either. The problem is that nominal yields have been rising not due to inflation, but because of the increase in real interest rates, as one can see in the chart below.
Chart 4: US real interest rates (10-year Treasury indexed by inflation, in %) from January 2014 to October 2018.
This is bad news for gold. We believe that the current macroeconomic environment remains negative for the yellow metal (although the outlook is brighter). The recent rebound is understandable given the extreme bearish sentiment previously. However, the US economy expands nicely with nominal growth around 4 percent and inflation contained around 2 percent. With high corporate earnings and solid cash flow we believe that the stock market will continue its bull market and the moderate rise in bond yields should not change it, at least not immediately.