Renewable Energy is a Blackout Risk After Blackout

By Helen Cahill For The Mail On Sunday – Re-Blogged From This is Money

  •  Company has downplayed the role of wind energy in the power cut
  • In April a study warned renewable power sources could risk network’s ‘stability’ 
  •  Half UK’s power generated from wind at one point on the day the power failed

Boss of the National Grid John Pettigrew said the outage was a ‘once-in-30-years’ event

Boss of the National Grid John Pettigrew said the outage was a ‘once-in-30-years’ event

National Grid had evidence that the shift to renewable energy was putting Britain’s electricity supply at risk months before the biggest blackout in a decade, The Mail on Sunday can reveal.

The company, which is responsible for keeping the lights on, has downplayed the role of wind energy in the power cut that caused widespread chaos earlier this month.

John Pettigrew, chief executive of the FTSE 100 firm, described the outage as a ‘once-in-30-years’ event and said there was ‘nothing to indicate there is anything to do with the fact that we are moving to more wind or more solar’.

Yet in April, National Grid published research warning that using more renewable power sources posed a threat to the network’s ‘stability’.

In a report based on a £6.8 million research project, National Grid admitted that renewables increased the ‘unpredictability and volatility’ of the power supply which ‘could lead to faults on the electricity network’.

The revelations come as energy regulator Ofgem and the Government continue to investigate the causes of the blackout.

A report due out this week is expected to show the outage was caused by a series of failures, including a lightning strike which led to the almost simultaneous shutdown of two power stations.

A gas-fired power station at Little Barford, Bedfordshire, and the Hornsea offshore wind farm in the North Sea both went offline just before 5pm on August 9.

That caused the electricity network’s frequency – the rate at which power is transmitted to users – to drop below 50 Hz. Equipment can be damaged if it is higher or lower than this level.

To maintain frequency, local distribution networks were forced to cut supply in some areas.

Figures from the National Grid show almost half the UK’s power was generated from wind at one point on the day the power failed.

National Grid has developed a frequency ‘monitoring and control system’ to deal with issues arising from the drive to renewables.

It should be operational by 2025 when it expects to have moved to a ‘zero carbon’ electricity system.

Experts have said giant batteries providing instant back-up energy could help.

Jeremy Nicholson, an expert at energy consultancy Alfa, said: ‘This is not about wind being unreliable. It’s about having the right system in place to accommodate it. It’s a question of doing it safely. Wind enthusiasts acknowledge this.

‘The costs are sizeable but if there’s a risk of this happening more frequently, I don’t think businesses or consumers will accept a lower standard of continuity of supply.’

A spokesman for National Grid said: ‘As we move to a more renewable system we are creating new markets and products to manage this effectively.

‘We are confident we will be able to operate Britain’s electricity at zero carbon by 2025 with a safe and resilient network, given the right regulatory framework and incentives.’


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s